|Get to the MoreForMyHouse.com HOMEPAGE|Barrie Prices|Unpublished MLS listings|Real Estate FAQ's|First-Time Buyer's Guide|Viewers' E-Mailbag|Translate MLS Codes and REALTOR's Abbreviations| Search Canadian MLS Property Listings|Resources| Suppliers | Discount Commissions|Listing Examples| Appraisal for Your House |Complain About A Realtor|Become a Realtor|Site-Map|Email a question or feedback, Contact Bill|

Buy Lower/Sell Higher

www.MoreForMyHouse.com

Guess the future

 William (Bill) Rinehart, Realtor®/Salesperson

HomeLife/Kempenfelt-Kelly Realty Ltd, Broker

705.436.5111

Where is the market going in 2010?

The statistics in When should I buy? demonstrated how different buyers won or lost depending on how they timed their home purchases before, during, and after the big boom and crash of the 80's housing market in Barrie. Buying at the right time in the market cycle can make a huge difference in your retirement plans.

The 1980's housing boom that crashed badly in 1990 was considered an illogical bubble market. It can be compared to the historic tulip frenzy in Europe, back in whatever century that was. The tulip frenzy was also comparable to the Tech Stock craze crash-and-burn at the turn of the 21st century.

Those 1980's real-estate prices were supposed to be crazy overheated real-estate prices that we would never see again.

After converting those crazy 1990 house prices into 2009 dollars, so as to compare apples to apples, most people in Simcoe County have been paying more for houses than they were in those crazy days of the 80's housing boom; as much as 50% more in one township. If people were crazy in 1989, what does that make them now?!

Where do we go from here?

$349,900 Builders home in Innisfil near lake. 1 year old 1900 sq ft on large lot. Click pic for more houses.

(Skip the history and cut to the chase)

Why is it significant that people have been paying so much for houses?

People have all kinds of things to spend money on. They choose which things are priorities and will get a larger share of their expenditures.

Sometimes, the population decides that having a roof over their head is a greater priority than other needs, and they will be willing to spend more money than usual to get that roof, even taking money away from other lesser priorities. House prices rise as supply can't keep up with demand.

At other times, the shelter and home isn't as great a priority for the population, compared to the other demands they have on their money. Then there's way too much supply, and no demand, so prices fall.

Because of that, the real estate market has always gone through cycles of approximately 5 years of growth followed by 5 years of declining prices.

I think of it as a sine wave with the positive and negative peaks being the irrational high and low extremes of the market, and the zero point being the point of rationality when houses are given a realistic priority in peoples lives, and rational prices prevail.

We passed the rational zero point on the sine wave for our current market cycle somewhere between 1995 and 2000.

What goes up usually goes back down.

$349,900 Builders home in Innisfil near lake. 1 year old 1900 sq ft on large lot. Click pic for more houses.

Around 2000, most observers assumed that we were at or near the top of the curve, and prices would start to go down over the next year or so.

Not only did they continued to go up after 2000, but the rate of annual increases began to rise, leading most observers to believe that a bubble market was being created. A balloon can only get so big before it bursts.

Rapid house value increases can't be sustained over the long-term. If average prices (and mortgage payments) increase at a faster rate than the average buyer's salary increases, you eventually get to the point where nobody can afford to buy houses, and prices begin to come down.

Considering that we were in the eleventh year of a five year cycle, and that prices were increasing at an unsustainable rate, most observers were predicting that a "correction" would bring prices back down in 2005/2006. The great unknowns was how much of a drop in prices there would be, and what would be the catalyst to kick-start the correction.

For a while, it actually looked like there had been a "correction" in the housing market and that everyone had come out of it unscathed. In the last half of 2005, price growth slowed, turning the 10% growth from Jan - June into a 7% annual increase by the end of the year. Increases slowed to a more sustainable 5-6% range in 2006 and 2007.

Price increases slowed to a moderate rate in most of the GTA. They were slightly higher than the general inflation rate which means they were not rising rapidly in investment terms. It looked like the "correction" had occurred with the best possible outcome.

Then the bottom fell out of the US housing market. Banks failed. Massive rescue packages. Our government, trying to re-elected, insisted there was no recession while, at the same time, most economists acknowledged that the Provincial economies of Ontario and Quebec were in a recession, and the Canadian economy was borderline or also in one.

Early in this century, the Canadian economy slowed down, partly as a result of the Tech-stock crash. (Another bubble market.) Terrorists also managed to fly jets into the biggest buildings in New York during that time. Those are the kinds of shots to the head would stall any normal re-sale market, but the buyers kept buying. They continued to push house prices up.

What happens next depends on the buyers.

 

The Barrie market in 2010

$349,900 Builders home in Innisfil near lake. 1 year old 1900 sq ft on large lot. Click pic for more houses.

Those of my followers who took my advice (stay in your parent's basement, save your money, and buy when everyone else is trying to sell) will soon be able to crawl out of your parent's basement and buy a house.

We've been in a "seller's market" since 1995. Whether it's a buyer's or seller's market is determined by statistics. Those statistics pointed to a strong sellers market for most of the last 13 years, but showed signs of a softening market in 2007.

Those statistics are currently (Is it a Buyer's or Seller's Market?) describing a market on the tipping point. In the first quarter of 2009, we slipped into a buyer's market. February looked like the bubble had finally burst. March and April bucked the trend though, and where the market goes next is dependent on how the market reacts to whatever economic news hits next.

If you bought into the buy low/sell high philosophy of my website, you'll know that the best time to buy is at the bottom of the market. I can't tell you when that will be, but if you stick with me I will tell you when we have passed it and when it is safe to buy (when prices are on the way up, not farther down.)

Resale values dropped over 30% in the GTA in the last housing crash. The most credible housing numbers are produced by the Teranet/National Bank Housing Index which is forecasting resale house prices/values in the GTA will drop by 20% before the market begins to recover.

We haven't seen that scenario play out, yet, because of two external influences:

A - Artificially low mortgage rates; Banks normally sell bonds to raise the cash that they give to us through mortgages. Given the state of the banks when they almost collapsed, the banks would have to offer 20% bonds to investors to get anyone to buy them. That would have driven mortgage rates to a point where the foreclosure crisis seen in the USA would have hit Canada. To avoid that, our Federal Government has been giving the banks the money (at 0.25%) to give back to us as 5% mortgages. The banks are not complaining.

B - As I have been warning everyone (Who Should Buy in 2010) if you buy a house with no money down, and the value of the house doesn't go up, you can't afford to sell it and pay off the mortgage.

80% of the mortgage taken out in the 5 years before the economic crisis hit, were between 0%-5% down. House values have not moved in two years. Most of those minimum down buyers are sitting in houses that would normally be cycling back onto the market. They can't get enough for the house to pay off the mortgage, the legal fees and the Realtors' fees, so those houses are not for sale.

Added to that, are the people who COULD sell their house, but aren't because they think a recession is a bad time to sell.

Those factors have created an artifical shortage of supply. Without those influences, resale house values would be closer to the 30% losses witnessed in the 1990's crash.

In July of this year, a new 8% provicial sales tax will be slapped on new home sales. That will kill the housing industry (which drives the Ontario economy) and send swarms of former new-home purchasers into the resale market and further exacerbate the shortage. Resale values should rise.

At the same time, there is a bill before Parliament, (or was before Dictator Harper prorogued Parliament for the secod time,) to raise the minimum downpayment a buyer must have to get a mortgage. It's currently 5% (after briefly being zero) and would likely be raised to 10%. That's a refreshing development when you consider how the banks profit from Canadians being slaves to our debt, but in the short-term that will have a detrimental affect on the resale housing market. If it happens.

At some point, even our government has to deal with its own debt. It can't keep giving the banks free money (taken out of our pockets as taxes.) At some point the banks have to go back to the bond market. Nobody knows how that is going to affect mortgage interest rates, but consider this; if the rates are 5% when the bank is backing them with free money, how high will they go if the banks are paying 10% to get their bonds sold?

If you're a homeowner in Barrie, with at least 30% equity in your house, there is no reason to lose sleep based on a few months' statistics. If you're thinking it's a bad time to sell, you're justified in thinking so, but you're wrong. If have a house to sell, get it on the market NOW.

If you're a buyer, but are holding off, be assured that the market is not getting away from you. Resale prices at the end of 2009 haven't changed from 2008's levels. You can wait to buy, or if you've prepared yourself as I advise (see Who Should Buy in 2010?) you could be one of the buyers who sees it as an opportunity, not as a threat. When you decide that it's time for you to buy, call me and we'll go find you that bargain!

Where should I buy a house?

When should I buy?

Where is the market going?

Who made the most?

How do I buy lower?

How do I sell higher?

Back to HomePage

Contact Bill

Bill Rinehart

 705 436-5111

Toll Free 1-877-436-5111

© WRinehart2009 All rights reserved.

Reproduction or distribution without the express written consent of the author is prohibited under international copyright law